Book a Consultation

Informal Wills Under Section 9: Authorisation and Risk 

An informal will in Victoria can be legally recognised under section 9 of the Wills Act, even without formal execution. However, proving intention often leads to probate disputes. This article explores when courts accept informal wills and the risks involved.
Melbourne lawyer reviewing an informal will document in Victoria

Key Takeaways

  • Informal wills in Victoria can be admitted to probate under section 9 of the Wills Act 1997 (Vic), even if they do not meet formal execution requirements.
  • The courts focus on the testamentary intention of the deceased when evaluating informal wills, often leading to disputes due to the need for surrounding evidence.
  • Clear testamentary intention and consistency with prior statements are crucial for the acceptance of an informal will by the courts.
  • Informal wills often lead to probate disputes due to ambiguities regarding intention, competing beneficiaries, and the potential for allegations of undue influence.
  • For high-value estates, relying on informal wills can increase litigation exposure, diminish estate value, and lead to unintended distributions.
Quick Definition

What is an informal will in Victoria?

An informal will in Victoria is a document that expresses a person’s testamentary intentions but does not meet the formal legal requirements of a valid will. Courts can still recognise it under section 9 of the Wills Act 1997 (Vic) if satisfied that the deceased intended the document to operate as their will. However, because intention must be proven, informal wills are more likely to lead to a probate challenge and disputes between beneficiaries.

An informal will in Victoria can arise in unexpected ways — through an unsigned will, a digital note, or even a message expressing testamentary intentions. Under section 9 of the Wills Act 1997 (Vic), courts may admit a testamentary document to probate even if it does not meet formal execution requirements. However, while a successful s9 application can validate such documents, it often opens the door to a probate challenge, increasing the risk of disputes among beneficiaries. 

For high-value estates, the stakes are significant. Understanding when courts authorise informal wills — and why disputes arise — is essential for safeguarding testamentary intentions and minimising litigation risk. 

What Is an Informal Will in Victoria? 

An informal will in Victoria refers to a document that expresses a deceased person’s testamentary intentions but fails to comply with strict execution requirements. These typically include: 

  • Being in writing 
  • Signed by the testator 
  • Witnessed by two individuals 

Where these elements are absent, the document is considered “informal.” However, section 9 allows the Supreme Court of Victoria to dispense these requirements if certain criteria are met. 

Informal wills can take many forms, including: 

  • Draft or unsigned wills 
  • Notes stored on a phone or computer 
  • Letters or emails expressing wishes 
  • Amendments to an existing will not properly executed 

These documents may still be recognised as a valid testamentary document, provided the court is satisfied of the deceased’s intention. 

Section 9 of the Wills Act: A Flexible but Risky Pathway 

Section 9 of the Wills Act 1997 (Vic) provides the mechanism for admitting informal wills to probate. The broader probate framework can be understood through the Administration and Probate Act 1958 (Vic). 

The court must be satisfied that: 

  1. A document exists; and 
  1. The deceased intended it to operate as their will (or part of it) 

This second requirement — intention — is the central issue in any s9 application. 

Unlike formal wills, which benefit from presumptions of validity, informal wills require intention to be proven through surrounding evidence. This introduces uncertainty and increases the likelihood of a probate challenge. 

When Courts Admit Informal Wills 

Courts in Victoria adopt a practical approach, focusing on intention rather than strict form. 

1. Clear Testamentary Intention 

The strongest cases involve documents that clearly demonstrate final intention, such as: 

  • A document outlining how assets are to be distributed 
  • Language indicating finality (e.g., “this is my will”) 
  • Instructions that are not merely preparatory 

Where a document appears complete and deliberate, the court is more likely to accept it as a valid testamentary document. 

2. Evidence of Deliberate Creation 

Courts will consider how and why the document was created, including: 

  • Timing (particularly near death) 
  • Whether it was stored securely or shared 
  • Attempts to formalise it 

Even an unsigned will may be admitted if there is sufficient evidence that the deceased intended it to take effect. 

3. Consistency with Prior Statements or Conduct 

If the document aligns with previously expressed wishes — such as conversations, earlier wills, or written communications — it strengthens the case for authorisation and supports a successful s9 application. 

4. Absence of Competing Documents 

Where no formal will exists — or the informal document clearly supersedes earlier versions — the court is more likely to accept it. 

Informal will dispute lawyers Melbourne consultation
Legal advice for informal will disputes in Victoria

When Informal Wills Are Rejected 

Not all informal wills succeed. Courts will refuse to admit a document where intention is unclear. 

1. Draft or Preparatory Documents 

A document that is a draft — particularly one intended for later execution — may fail unless there is compelling evidence of final intention. 

2. Ambiguous Language 

Vague or incomplete instructions about beneficiaries, assets, or finality can undermine validity. 

3. Evidence of Changing Intentions 

Where conflicting intentions appear across documents or statements, the court may be unable to determine the deceased’s final wishes — often triggering a probate challenge. 

Why Informal Wills Often Lead to Probate Disputes 

While section 9 provides flexibility, it also creates fertile ground for litigation. 

1. Uncertainty Around Intention 

The central question — whether the deceased intended the document to operate as their will — is frequently contested. Different interpretations often lead to competing claims and disputed s9 applications. For tailored guidance, explore our wills & estates legal services. 

2. Competing Beneficiaries 

Informal wills often disrupt expected distributions, particularly where: 

  • A later informal document alters entitlements 
  • Family members dispute authenticity or meaning 

These situations frequently lead to Supreme Court proceedings, particularly in higher-value estates. Learn more about your options through our probate disputes and litigation services. 

3. Allegations of Undue Influence or Lack of Capacity 

Because informal wills lack witnesses, they are more vulnerable to claims of: 

  • Undue influence 
  • Fraud or fabrication 
  • Lack of testamentary capacity 

This increases evidentiary complexity and dispute risk. 

4. Multiple Documents and Revocation Issues 

Where several documents exist — formal and informal — the court must determine which represents the final intention and whether earlier wills were revoked. 

This can significantly delay estate administration and increase costs. For broader insights into estate conflicts, including disputes over informal wills, visit our contested estates hub. 

Dealing with an Informal Will or Probate Dispute?

Informal wills can trigger disputes, delay estate administration, and expose beneficiaries to costly litigation. Early legal advice can clarify your position and reduce risk.

Speak with a Lawyer

Confidential, strategic advice tailored to your situation.

The Strategic Risks for High-Value Estates 

For affluent individuals and complex estates, reliance on an informal will in Victoria presents material risks. 

Increased Litigation Exposure 

A disputed informal will can lead to prolonged litigation, reducing estate value through legal costs and delays. 

Loss of Control Over Distribution 

If the informal will fails, the estate may be distributed under a prior will — or intestacy — producing unintended outcomes. 

Reputational and Family Impact 

Disputes often escalate into broader family conflict, particularly where significant assets or business interests are involved. 

Minimising Risk: Practical Considerations 

While section 9 provides a safety net, it should not replace proper estate planning. 

To reduce the risk of a failed s9 application or probate challenge: 

  • Ensure wills are properly executed and updated 
  • Avoid reliance on informal or digital records 
  • Seek legal advice when making changes 
  • Clearly revoke prior wills 

For high-value estates, tailored legal advice is critical to ensure enforceability and minimise disputes. 

Frequently Asked Questions 

What is a section 9 application? 

A s9 application is a court application seeking to have an informal document recognised as a valid will by proving the deceased intended it to operate as such. 

Can an unsigned will be valid in Victoria? 

Yes, an unsigned will can be admitted if the court is satisfied it reflects final testamentary intention, although this often leads to disputes. 

What qualifies as a testamentary document? 

A testamentary document is any document expressing how a person wishes their estate to be distributed after death. 

Why are informal wills often challenged? 

They lack formal safeguards, making them more vulnerable to a probate challenge based on intention, authenticity, and competing claims. 

Is it risky to rely on an informal will? 

Yes. While possible to validate, the process is uncertain, time-consuming, and often contentious. 

Can a text message or digital note be a valid informal will in Victoria? 

Yes, if it clearly shows the deceased intended it to operate as their will. However, it is more likely to face a probate challenge due to evidentiary uncertainty. 

How long does a section 9 application take in Victoria? 

Most s9 applications take several months to resolve. Timeframes may extend if a probate challenge arises, or the matter is contested. 

Certainty vs Risk: Protecting Your Estate from Dispute 

Section 9 provides a critical safeguard for genuine testamentary intentions, but every informal will in Victoria introduces uncertainty. The need to prove intention often invites a probate challenge, increasing costs, delays, and the risk of outcomes that do not reflect the deceased’s wishes. 

Logo of Pentana Stanton Lawyers, a Melbourne-based law firm.
Pentana Stanton Lawyers: Your Trusted Legal Experts in Melbourne.

To protect your estate and minimise the risk of dispute, your testamentary intentions must be clearly documented and legally enforceable. Pentana Stanton Lawyers provides strategic, high-level advice on estate planning and s9 applications, ensuring your position is defensible and your wishes are upheld — engage our team today for decisive, expert guidance. 

About the author
Picture of Sarah LaGreca
Sarah LaGreca
Sarah LaGreca is a Solicitor at Pentana Stanton Lawyers, practising across wills and estates, family law, and commercial law. A Juris Doctor graduate of Monash University, she also holds qualifications in psychology, education, and clinical psychology, bringing a genuinely multidisciplinary approach to her legal work. Sarah is known for her clear communication, warm manner, and ability to make complex legal processes feel manageable for her clients.
Further reading

Related insights

Client reviews

What our clients say

Enquire

Discuss your matter with our team

Tell us a little about your situation and we will be in touch to arrange a consultation. Your enquiry is confidential.

Confidential enquiry