Key Takeaways
- Distinction between personal exertion goodwill (non‑transferable, reflecting the practitioner’s skills and future earning capacity) and commercial/enterprise goodwill (transferable business value that can form part of divisible property) — the legal outcome depends on separating these sources of value.
- Family Law Act framework in Victoria: s79(3)–(5) requires identification of property and liabilities, consideration of contributions and current/future circumstances, and that any adjustment be just and equitable; these provisions shape how practice goodwill and earning capacity are treated in property settlements.
- Valuation complexities and evidentiary dependence: transferability, trading systems, staff, client relationships, and ‘value to the owner’ versus market value approaches matter; capitalised future maintainable earnings must show sustainable earnings, adjustments and the chosen multiple — case law (e.g. Gare & Farlow; Carver & Munshi; Goddard & Patterson) shows outcomes turn on the evidence and methodology.
- Double‑counting risk: the same economic benefit must not be given unjustified weight twice — a valuation must state which earnings underpin the capital value and any s79(5) adjustment for unequal earning capacity must be considered against that valuation to avoid duplication.
- Practical preparation and challenge strategy: identify the precise interest being valued, provide full financial records and ownership/transfer documents, require the valuer to treat personal exertion goodwill explicitly, consider settlement funding/liquidity, and obtain expert/legal advice before accepting or disputing a valuation.
Quick Answer
Is professional practice goodwill included in a property settlement?
Yes. Professional practice goodwill can contribute to the value of a practice interest included in a property settlement. Commercial or enterprise goodwill may form part of that value, while non-transferable personal goodwill generally represents the practitioner’s earning capacity rather than a separate property asset.
The valuation should distinguish value generated by staff, systems and business relationships from income dependent on the practitioner’s continued work. Limited saleability does not automatically mean the practice has no value.
Any proposed adjustment for unequal earning capacity should account for what the practice valuation already captures, so the same economic benefit does not receive unjustified weight twice.
Does a professional practice’s goodwill form part of a property settlement after separation?
For practice owners and their spouses in Victoria, commercial or enterprise goodwill can form part of the divisible property, while non-transferable personal goodwill is generally treated as earning capacity rather than a separate property asset.
Assessing professional practice goodwill in a property settlement in Australia requires separating those sources of value. A practice may be the couple’s largest asset, yet its reported profits do not establish how much goodwill it holds. Client relationships, staff, systems, and transferability all require examination, alongside the practice’s value to the owner.
Under the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth), section 79(4) addresses contributions, while section 79(5) addresses current and future circumstances, including income and earning capacity. Personal exertion goodwill therefore requires careful treatment: future work should not simply be converted into an asset available for division.
The valuation must also be read alongside any proposed adjustment for future circumstances. Double counting can arise where the same earnings underpin both the practice valuation and a further adjustment without adequate allowance for that overlap.
How Does Australian Family Law Treat Professional Practice Goodwill in a Property Settlement?
In Victoria, the treatment of professional practice goodwill in a property settlement is governed by the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth). For married couples, section 79(3) requires the court to identify existing property and liabilities. Section 79(4) addresses contributions, including financial and parenting contributions. Section 79(5) addresses current and future circumstances, including income, financial resources and capacity for employment. Any alteration of property interests must be just and equitable under section 79(2).
Commercial or enterprise goodwill can contribute to the value of a spouse’s practice interest. In Wall and Wall (Full Court, unreported, 26 October 2000), the court distinguished non-transferable personal goodwill, representing earning capacity, from commercial goodwill. It also cautioned against treating owner dependence as proof that no commercial goodwill exists.
Consistently with that distinction, in Goddard & Patterson [2011] FamCAFC 14, the Full Court upheld findings that most goodwill depended on the husband’s non-transferable skills and reputation and that any commercial element was minimal. It also upheld consideration of the business’s future prospects under the then-applicable section 75(2). Under the current property framework, current and future circumstances are addressed in section 79(5). The decision does not establish that every owner-dependent practice lacks property value.
Transferability is relevant, but a restricted market does not make a practice worthless. The court may consider its value to the owner, including benefits of retaining the business that a hypothetical purchaser would not enjoy.
In Gare & Farlow [2023] FedCFamC2F 109, Judge Forbes accepted a value-to-owner valuation of AUD 429,500 despite the absence of a written commercial lease. The reasoning considered the wife’s continuing financial benefits, secure occupation through her father, and intention to retain the business.
In Carver & Munshi [2022] FedCFamC2F 607, the court accepted the independent expert’s AUD 352,000 healthcare practice valuation using capitalised future maintainable earnings. It rejected the proposed value-to-owner approach on the evidence. These first-instance decisions illustrate why the valuation approach depends on the business and the evidence.
The distinction also matters when assessing double counting. A valuation should explain which earnings support the capital value and how the practitioner’s work has been allowed for. Any subsequent adjustment for unequal earning capacity must then be considered alongside that valuation. Taking income into account at both stages is not automatically an error, but the same economic benefit must not receive unjustified duplicate weight.

How Do Courts Assess Professional Practice Goodwill in a Property Settlement?
What value belongs to the practice rather than the practitioner?
The court needs evidence of what generates the practice’s income. Established systems, employed practitioners, recurring engagements and a recognised trading name may support commercial or enterprise goodwill. Revenue dependent on one professional’s reputation and continued work raises questions about personal exertion goodwill.
In Goddard & Patterson, the evidence supported findings that clients were gained mainly through the husband’s skills and reputation, his personal skills were not transferable, and commercial goodwill was minimal. The Full Court upheld those findings. The practical question is which advantages belong to the business, and which depend on the individual.
What evidence establishes transferability?
Transferability requires examining what a purchaser could acquire. Partnership or shareholder agreements, admission requirements, leases, client arrangements, and restraints may affect whether an interest can be transferred and on what terms. Client retention cannot be assumed.
For the other spouse, a claim that the practice “cannot be sold” should be tested against those documents. For the practitioner, the evidence should explain which restrictions affect market value, and which benefits remain available through continued ownership.
When will the court consider value to the owner?
A limited market does not end the valuation exercise. In Gare & Farlow, the court examined the continuing benefits available to the wife, including secure occupation despite the absence of a written lease. Those circumstances supported value to the owner.
Carver & Munshi demonstrates that this approach is not automatic. The court accepted the expert’s earnings-based valuation and rejected the proposed alternative. The practical question is what evidence supports additional value to the owner, rather than whether that owner wishes to retain the practice. Value to the owner is a valuation basis, not a substitute for a supported calculation.
How should future maintainable earnings be assessed?
A valuation using capitalised future maintainable earnings should explain the sustainable earnings figure, adjustments to the accounts and the chosen multiple. The report should identify how remuneration for the practitioner’s work is treated and distinguish that work from returns generated by the business.
The practice’s trading history, dependence on key people and prospects for retaining revenue matter. In Carver & Munshi, the court accepted the expert’s reasoning about the practice’s early development and risk when assessing the earnings multiple. Forecast growth requires evidence, not an assumption that expansion will succeed.
When does considering income create a double-counting risk?
Double counting requires examining the valuation alongside any proposed section 79(5) adjustment for unequal earning capacity. The question is whether the same economic benefit receives unjustified weight twice.
Capitalising earnings does not itself remove future income or establish duplication. In Gare & Farlow, the court rejected the contention that capitalisation would deprive the wife of effective future income. Each proposed adjustment therefore needs a clear explanation of what the valuation already captures and what remains relevant to future circumstances.
What Disputes Arise Over Professional Practice Goodwill After Separation?
Disputes over professional practice goodwill often concern the boundary between income earned by the practitioner and value held in the business. For the practitioner retaining the practice, an inflated valuation can increase the payment required to settle the other spouse’s entitlement. For the other spouse, treating all profits as personal exertion goodwill can understate the value of an established enterprise. Neither position can be resolved from turnover or the owner’s description of the practice alone.
Restrictions on sale are a recurring point of contention. In Gare & Farlow, the wife’s business operated from premises owned by her father without a written commercial lease. The absence of a lease limited its saleability, but the court examined the benefits she continued to enjoy and accepted a value to the owner of AUD 429,500. The dispute demonstrates why transferability and the economic benefits of continued ownership require separate examination.
Incomplete financial information can also prolong proceedings and undermine confidence in a valuation. In Carver & Munshi, the adequacy of the expert’s reports and the information supplied to him contributed to the trial being heard in three tranches. The court accepted his AUD 352,000 valuation, finding that he had sufficient information and had explained his methodology. The wife’s proposed alternative did not persuade the court; she had not produced evidence from another valuer.
Disagreement about capitalised future maintainable earnings frequently centres on remuneration, sustainable revenue, and the earnings multiple. A challenge must identify the disputed assumption and explain its effect on value. A higher figure advanced in submissions does not carry the same evidentiary weight as a supported expert opinion.
Double counting can arise within the property calculation itself. In Gare & Farlow, the court declined to add renovation expenditure back into the asset pool because the valuation had already addressed that expenditure through adjustments to earnings and amortisation. That finding concerns duplication within the valuation and property exercise. It should not be treated as a ruling that any later consideration of earning capacity necessarily counts the same income twice.
Is the Practice Valuation Shaping Your Settlement?
Whether you own the practice or need to assess your spouse’s interest, understand what the valuation includes before agreeing to a settlement. Pentana Stanton Lawyers can help you assess the evidence, identify disputed assumptions and consider practical settlement options.
Book a Confidential ConsultationWhat Evidence Should You Prepare Before Negotiating a Professional Practice Valuation?
Before commissioning a valuation, identify the precise interest being valued: shares in a company, a partnership interest or a business held personally. The instructions should distinguish that interest from separately owned premises, shareholder loans, and other assets so that amounts are not omitted or counted twice.
Give the valuer financial statements, tax returns, current management accounts and the agreements governing ownership and transferability. These records also support compliance with financial disclosure obligations. Explain changes in practitioner hours, referral sources, staffing, and revenue since separation. Records of actual performance provide a stronger foundation than unsupported projections of growth or decline.
The report should make the treatment of personal exertion goodwill explicit. Ask how the practitioner’s remuneration has been assessed, what earnings remain attributable to the business, and which benefits support any value to the owner. Where capitalised future maintainable earnings are used, test the earnings adjustments and multiple separately. A disagreement about the final figure is more useful when traced to an identifiable assumption.
Before challenging an expert report, obtain advice on whether clarification, corrected source material or further expert evidence would address the problem. Carver & Munshi illustrates the limits of advancing an alternative valuation through submissions without competing expert support.
Finally, assess settlement funding alongside the valuation. A practice may have substantial value without providing readily available cash. Consider available finance, repayment obligations, and the effect of proposed orders on continued operations. Any claim for an adjustment based on unequal earning capacity should identify what the valuation already captures and explain the remaining disparity. That analysis helps expose double counting and supports a settlement proposal grounded in both evidence and financial reality.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is my professional practice included in a divorce property settlement?
Yes. Your ownership interest in a professional practice can form part of the property considered in a settlement in Victoria. Its value may include commercial or enterprise goodwill, depending on the evidence. The assessment must distinguish the business interest from your future earning capacity and account for its structure and liabilities. Inclusion in the property pool does not necessarily mean the practice must be sold.
What is the difference between personal and business goodwill in divorce?
Personal exertion goodwill depends on the practitioner’s individual skills, reputation, and continuing work. Business goodwill arises from advantages attached to the practice, such as systems, staff and client relationships that can support ongoing revenue. A practice can contain both, so the owner’s involvement does not establish that all goodwill is personal. The valuation should explain which sources of value belong to the business and how they have been assessed.
Does my practice have value if I cannot sell it?
Yes, it may. Limited transferability does not automatically reduce a practice interest to its net assets or make it worthless. A value to the owner assessment may recognise benefits that remain available through continued ownership, even where a purchaser would not receive them. The court accepted that approach in Gare & Farlow, but its suitability depends on the evidence in each case.
Can my future income be counted twice in a property settlement?
Double counting is a risk, but using earnings in a valuation and considering income later is not automatically an error. Capitalised future maintainable earnings estimate business value, while section 79(5) addresses current and future circumstances. The analysis must identify any overlap between the benefits already valued and a proposed adjustment for unequal earning capacity. A claim of duplication needs that explanation.
Can I challenge the valuation of my spouse’s practice?
Yes. You can question the information, assumptions, and methodology supporting the valuation. Identify specific issues, such as incomplete accounts, unsupported growth forecasts, or the treatment of practitioner remuneration. Obtain advice about clarification questions and whether further expert evidence is appropriate. In Carver & Munshi, the court rejected the proposed alternative and accepted the independent expert’s valuation after examining his reasoning.
How Should You Approach a Property Settlement Involving Professional Practice Goodwill?
A professional practice’s value cannot be determined simply by labelling its goodwill personal or commercial. The evidence must separate the business interest from future earning capacity, explain any value to the owner, and support the proposed valuation method. Limited transferability does not settle the issue, and concerns about double counting require a clear account of what has already been valued.
For practice owners and their spouses in Victoria, those distinctions affect both settlement entitlements and the practical ability to retain the business. Before accepting a valuation or negotiating payment terms, seek advice that connects the family law position with the practice’s financial and ownership arrangements.

Pentana Stanton Lawyers advises on family law for business owners. Book a consultation to discuss your practice interest, valuation evidence, and settlement options.
This article is general information only and not legal advice. For advice specific to your circumstances, please contact our team.




