The High Court found that the phrase “instant Botox® alternative” was used descriptively rather than as a trade mark. It did not function as a badge of origin and was not used to distinguish goods under the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth).
The Court clarified that a trade mark’s commercial reputation (e.g., BOTOX) is not relevant when assessing deceptive similarity under section 120(1). The focus must be on how the marks appear on the Register—not how well-known the product is.
The High Court ruled that the name PROTOX was not deceptively similar to BOTOX, reversing the Full Court’s finding and reaffirming that consumer confusion must be based on the mark itself, not market context or fame.
The Court found that Self Care’s advertising, including the phrase “instant Botox® alternative”, did not mislead or deceive consumers under the ACL. The context, packaging, and explanatory wording made the limited effect duration clear.
This decision provides strong guidance for businesses, confirming that responsible comparative marketing and descriptive phrases are lawful when properly contextualised and do not mislead consumers or infringe trade mark rights.
Jesse LaGreca is a Partner and Principal Solicitor at Pentana Stanton Lawyers, admitted to practise before the Supreme Court of Victoria and the High Court of Australia. A graduate of Monash University (Law) and La Trobe University (Business), Jesse specialises in commercial law, family law, and professional negligence, with particular expertise in complex property disputes and advising entrepreneurs and growing businesses. His practical, results-driven approach — spanning advisory work through to court advocacy — ensures clients receive comprehensive representation at every stage of their matter.
{"slugs":{"case-summary":[0,"caseSummary"],"legal-explainer":[1,"explainer"],"legal-videos":[2,"video"],"commercial-lawyers":[3,"commercial"],"commercial":[3,"commercial"],"commercial-litigation":[3,"commercial"],"debt-recovery":[3,"commercial"],"business-lawyers":[3,"commercial"],"shareholder-disputes":[3,"commercial"],"shareholder-oppression":[3,"commercial"],"business-disputes":[3,"commercial"],"civil-litigation":[3,"commercial"],"litigation-lawyers":[3,"commercial"],"self-managed-superannuation-fund":[3,"commercial"],"defamation-law":[3,"commercial"],"insolvency-director-protection":[3,"commercial"],"insolvency-lawyers":[3,"commercial"],"insolvency-restructuring":[3,"commercial"],"professional-negligence-law":[3,"commercial"],"professional-negligence-law-2":[3,"commercial"],"professional-negligence-lawyers":[3,"commercial"],"duty-of-care-professional-liability-claims":[3,"commercial"],"buy-outs-and-exits":[3,"commercial"],"contracts-dispute-resolution":[3,"commercial"],"tax-disputes":[3,"commercial"],"tax-litigation":[3,"commercial"],"taxation-law":[3,"commercial"],"corporate-governance":[3,"commercial"],"corporate-lawyers":[3,"commercial"],"retail-commercial-leasing":[3,"commercial"],"family-laws":[4,"family"],"divorce-lawyers":[4,"family"],"family-lawyer":[4,"family"],"property-financial-agreements":[4,"family"],"property-settlement-lawyers":[4,"family"],"parenting-orders":[4,"family"],"wills-estates":[5,"estates"],"estate-litigation":[5,"estates"],"estate-administration":[5,"estates"],"contesting-a-will":[5,"estates"],"wills-estate-disputes":[5,"estates"],"executor-disputes":[5,"estates"],"power-of-attorney":[5,"estates"]},"groups":{"caseSummary":"Case summary","explainer":"Legal explainer","video":"Video","commercial":"Commercial law","family":"Family law","estates":"Wills & estates"},"practices":{"commercial":{"label":"commercial law","url":"/commercial-law/"},"family":{"label":"family law","url":"/family-law/"},"estates":{"label":"wills & estates","url":"/estate-planning/"}},"team":["penny-lagreca","jesse-lagreca","sarah-lagreca","david-sewell","michael-jacobs","peter-wood","violet-lazari","paul-roberts","adam-lopez","nick-lionakis","shan-lynette-stevens","ariane-ang","tianzhen-summer-xia","keerththana-mcvilly","sefika-gungordu","jack-hall","mrinal-kotnala","ruth-aaron","joanna-layton","rozeb-vohra","nida-azad","nick-tesch","shipra-malhotra","maysa-taouk","gelisha-gopaul","vivian-klestorny","cindy-ngo","lakshi-piyathilake","uththara-karunanayaka"],"teamUrl":"/meet-the-team/","firmName":"Pentana Stanton Lawyers","text":{"readTime":"{n} min read","tocCount":"{n} sections","profile":"View profile","practice":"Explore {label}"}}/* Pentana Stanton / Article (single post) behaviour.
- Builds the "In this article" list from the post's own section headings (skipping the embedded
Key takeaways, Quick answer, CTA and FAQ blocks), highlights the section being read, and draws
the reading-progress line.
- Adds the practice label and reading time to the hero, and the practice link to the side card
(mapped from the post's category-* classes, so messy category names never show).
- Links the author to their profile on the team page; an author who is not on the team (a
system account) is shown as the firm instead.
- Labels the related-article cards and reveals them on scroll.
No dependencies; runs once per page. */
(function () {
'use strict';if (document.readyState === 'loading') { document.addEventListener('DOMContentLoaded', init); } else { init(); }function init() {
var cfgEl = document.querySelector('script[data-pspt-cfg]');
if (!cfgEl || document.documentElement.hasAttribute('data-pspt-init')) return;
document.documentElement.setAttribute('data-pspt-init', '');var cfg = JSON.parse(cfgEl.textContent);
var reduced = window.matchMedia('(prefers-reduced-motion: reduce)').matches;
var article = document.querySelector('.pspt-article');
Array.prototype.forEach.call(document.querySelectorAll('.pspt'), function (el) { el.classList.add('pspt--js'); });var classes = postClasses();
setKicker(cfg, classes, article);
setPracticeLink(cfg, classes);
setAuthor(cfg);
markMissingImage();
labelCards(cfg);
if (article) { setupFaq(article); buildToc(cfg, article, reduced); }
reveal(reduced);
}// Theme Builder puts the post's classes (category-*, tag-*) on the single-post location wrapper.
function postClasses() {
var holder = document.querySelector('.elementor-location-single[class*="category-"]') || document.querySelector('article[class*="category-"]');
return holder ? Array.prototype.slice.call(holder.classList) : [];
}function best(cfg, classes, onlyPractice) {
var hit = null;
classes.forEach(function (c) {
if (c.indexOf('category-') !== 0) return;
var m = cfg.slugs[c.slice(9)];
if (!m || (onlyPractice && !cfg.practices[m[1]])) return;
if (!hit || m[0] = 2;
})[0];
if (level === 'H2') article.classList.add('pspt-article--h2');
var items = level ? heads.filter(function (h) { return h.tagName === level; }) : [];
var links = [];
var mq = window.matchMedia('(max-width: 1024px)');if (toc && box && list && items.length) {
var used = {};
items.forEach(function (h) {
if (!h.id) {
var base = 'pspt-' + (slugify(h.textContent).slice(0, 60) || 'section');
var id = base; var n = 2;
while (used[id] || document.getElementById(id)) { id = base + '-' + n++; }
h.id = id;
}
used[h.id] = true;
var li = document.createElement('li');
var a = document.createElement('a');
a.href = '#' + h.id;
a.textContent = h.textContent.trim();
a.addEventListener('click', function (e) {
e.preventDefault();
if (mq.matches) box.open = false;
h.scrollIntoView({ behavior: reduced ? 'auto' : 'smooth', block: 'start' });
if (history.replaceState) history.replaceState(null, '', '#' + h.id);
});
li.appendChild(a);
list.appendChild(li);
links.push(a);
});
var count = toc.querySelector('.pspt-toc__count');
if (count) count.textContent = cfg.text.tocCount.replace('{n}', items.length);
// Open on desktop (and not collapsible there); collapsed on tablet and phone.
box.open = !mq.matches;
var summary = box.querySelector('summary');
if (summary) summary.addEventListener('click', function (e) { if (!mq.matches) e.preventDefault(); });
if (mq.addEventListener) mq.addEventListener('change', function () { box.open = !mq.matches; });
} else if (toc) {
toc.classList.add('pspt-toc--empty');
}var active = -1;
var ticking = false;
function update() {
ticking = false;
var line = Math.min(160, window.innerHeight * 0.25);
var current = -1;
for (var i = 0; i < items.length; i++) {
if (items[i].getBoundingClientRect().top - line list.clientHeight) {
list.scrollTop = links[current].offsetTop - list.clientHeight / 2;
}
}
active = current;
}
if (bar) {
var r = article.getBoundingClientRect();
var total = r.height - window.innerHeight * 0.6;
var p = total > 0 ? Math.min(1, Math.max(0, -r.top / total)) : 0;
bar.style.transform = 'scaleX(' + p.toFixed(4) + ')';
}
}
function onScroll() { if (!ticking) { ticking = true; window.requestAnimationFrame(update); } }
window.addEventListener('scroll', onScroll, { passive: true });
window.addEventListener('resize', onScroll, { passive: true });
update();
}// ---------- Related-article cards: practice label + date ----------
function labelCards(cfg) {
Array.prototype.forEach.call(document.querySelectorAll('.pspt .elementor-post'), function (card) {
var text = card.querySelector('.elementor-post__text');
if (!text || text.querySelector('.pspt-cardkicker')) return;
var group = best(cfg, Array.prototype.slice.call(card.classList), false);
var date = card.querySelector('.elementor-post-date');
var kicker = document.createElement('p');
kicker.className = 'pspt-cardkicker';
if (group) {
var l = document.createElement('span');
l.className = 'pspt-cardkicker__label';
l.textContent = cfg.groups[group];
kicker.appendChild(l);
}
if (date) {
var d = document.createElement('span');
d.className = 'pspt-cardkicker__date';
d.textContent = date.textContent.trim();
kicker.appendChild(d);
}
text.insertBefore(kicker, text.firstChild);
});
var sizes = '(max-width: 600px) calc(100vw - 40px), (max-width: 1024px) calc(50vw - 40px), 380px';
Array.prototype.forEach.call(document.querySelectorAll('.pspt .elementor-post__thumbnail img'), function (img) { img.sizes = sizes; });
}function reveal(reduced) {
var items = document.querySelectorAll('.pspt-sec .elementor-post, .pspt-sec .pspt-head');
Array.prototype.forEach.call(items, function (el) { el.classList.add('pspt-reveal'); });
if (!('IntersectionObserver' in window) || reduced) {
Array.prototype.forEach.call(items, function (el) { el.classList.add('is-in'); });
return;
}
var io = new IntersectionObserver(function (entries) {
var n = 0;
entries.forEach(function (e) {
if (!e.isIntersecting) return;
e.target.style.setProperty('--d', Math.min(n++, 5) * 80 + 'ms');
e.target.classList.add('is-in');
io.unobserve(e.target);
});
}, { rootMargin: '0px 0px -8% 0px', threshold: 0.1 });
Array.prototype.forEach.call(items, function (el) { io.observe(el); });
}
})();
![澳大利亚高等法院的照片，象征着“Self Care 诉 Allergan”案 [2023] HCA 8 这一具有里程碑意义的裁决，该裁决澄清了澳大利亚法律下商标使用及误导性行为的相关规定，由 Pentana Stanton 律师事务所特别呈现。](https://pentanastanton.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2025/06/ChatGPT-Image-Jun-20-2025-02_16_58-PM-683x1024.png)
